After all this time... I still don't know
My LP is currently loaded with a SD Pearly gates Bridge and 59' Neck and I'm pretty happy with it to be honest. The Pearly Gates has gorgeous midrange characteristics, straight into the amp it puts you in AC/DC, Aerosmith, ZZ Top territory. Some people have looked at me like i was an idiot for putting a PG in a LP, and maybe they are right. Clean tones are probably better suited for country and you really have to roll off the treble, it has a very crisp, compressed, top end, which I find painful to the ears.
The 59' may seem a boring choice for the neck, but it is a classic LP spec which is why I went with it. It's brilliant for Joe Walsh type tones, clean strumming or mild overdrive, Rocky mountain way etc.
My Fret King Strat is packing the stock pickups, which are effectively 'old school' single coils in neck and mid and a 59' style humbucker in the bridge. I love the mid position for anything clean, it's just wonderful, the neck will get nice texas blues and the bridge does a very convincing early Van Halen.
I do love vintage pickups, and would never dream of anything else in a LP, but I think I may need to move onto something higher output, it's not that i need more drive. Vintage humbuckers have a big open sound and when you're cranked that can translate into 'wishy washy' overtones imo. So i think i maybe need something a bit 'tighter' for my next axe.
I'm thinking maybe a dimarzio super distortion in the strat!? Don't want to go to modern though, and rob it of that Van Haleny goodness
If any of my rambling strikes a chord with anyone, let me know what you think, the vintage vs modern debate is always an interesting one.
Rob